When the CEO becomes the problem: What history tells us about corporate scandals
The crisis surrounding Nvidia's Jensen Huang has raised an uncomfortable question for investors: what happens when a successful chief executive becomes a liability to the company they lead? Huang has resigned as Nvidia's chief executive following revelations about his personal relationships, including allegations that one involved a woman suspected by US intelligence of working for China. The uncertainty around the allegations and his resignation has unsettled investors. In what has been a volatile market for technology stocks, Nvidia's shares have fallen 19.3% since the first reports emerged, underperforming the SOX Index down 9.6% in the process. The shares are trading down a further 7% on 12 November following the resignation.

There is a surprisingly long history of chief executives losing their jobs over relationships with employees, including at McDonald's, Intel, Nestlé, BP and Boeing. The share-price reaction has often been relatively modest, even when the departure was unexpected. What happened afterwards is more interesting. Some businesses recovered quickly, while others suffered prolonged underperformance. The distinction appears to depend on the health of the underlying business, the quality of the succession plan and how much value investors attribute to the departing executive.
Nvidia presents a particularly interesting test of that history. Huang has led the company since its founding in 1993, making him far more closely associated with its strategy, technology and customer relationships than most corporate CEOs. His potential departure therefore raises questions that extend well beyond the scandal itself.
The market reaction has already been significant
The first reports linking Huang to a woman suspected of working for Chinese intelligence emerged on 29 October. His subsequent admission of an extramarital affair, the announcement of a board investigation and reports that the board is considering his removal have each added to the uncertainty. On 11 November, the press reported a second affair, with an Nvidia vice president, and Huang resigned as CEO shortly afterwards.
In many historical cases of scandal-hit CEO departures, the misconduct and the CEO’s exit became public in the same announcement. McDonald's, Intel, Boeing and Nestlé all disclosed the relationships alongside the change in leadership, leaving investors to assess both developments simultaneously. Nvidia is different. Its shareholders had almost two weeks to consider the allegations before Huang resigned.
The initial reactions to historic CEO departures elsewhere were generally contained. Boeing barely moved (0.1% lower) when Harry Stonecipher was dismissed in 2005, Intel fell 2.4% following Brian Krzanich's resignation in 2018, and McDonald's lost 2.7% when Steve Easterbrook was fired in 2019. Nestlé's dismissal of Laurent Freixe initially sent its shares down more than 3%, although the decline narrowed to 0.7% by the close.
The Hewlett-Packard experience was far more violent. Its shares fell 8.0% on the first trading day after Mark Hurd's resignation in 2010, wiping out ~$9bn of market value. The background was that Hurd had spent five years transforming HP, improving margins through aggressive cost control and overseeing a series of acquisitions. Investors were concerned about losing an executive credited with much of the company's success.
That Hewlett-Packard example is particularly relevant for Nvidia as Huang has played an even greater role in shaping the company's strategy, technology and market position. A substantial part of the investment case rests on confidence in his judgement, making the uncertainty surrounding his future especially significant.
Strong businesses have generally continued to perform post exit…
Boeing provides one of the clearest examples of companies and their share prices quickly moving past the upheaval. Boeing’s Stonecipher was removed in March 2005 following an affair with another executive but the dismissal also came at a favourable point in the aerospace cycle. The shares were 12% higher after three months and 27% higher after twelve months. Operating momentum also continued to strengthen, with group revenue rising 15% as aircraft deliveries increased. Boeing's strong order book and recovering aircraft demand ultimately proved far more important than the leadership upheaval.
McDonald's offers a similar illustration. Easterbrook was widely credited with revitalising the business before being dismissed in November 2019. His successor, Chris Kempczinski, was named immediately, having previously run the US business and helped implement the group's existing strategy. Despite the COVID pandemic, the shares ultimately rose 11% 12 months after the scandal as the franchise proved capable of continuing without the executive who had overseen its turnaround.
Booking.com (then Priceline) is interesting because the company did not have a permanent successor ready when Darren Huston resigned in April 2016 over a relationship with an employee, leaving chairman Jeff Boyd as interim CEO. Nevertheless, the shares were 2.1% below their pre-news close after three months but 36.4% above it after twelve. Ultimately, the company retained experienced operational leadership and continued benefiting from the structural growth of online travel.
Nestlé is the most recent example. Freixe was dismissed in September 2025 after an undisclosed relationship with a subordinate, becoming the group's second CEO departure in just over a year. His successor, Philipp Navratil, was promoted immediately from within the company. Six weeks later, Navratil announced 16,000 job cuts and a more ambitious savings programme, triggering the share price to record its strongest daily gain since 2008. In other words, the change at the top was used as an opportunity to accelerate the turnaround. The shares were 4.7% above their pre-news close after three months and 4.2% above it after twelve months as Nestlé's performance has improved.
… While a difficult succession can compound existing problems
Intel, Hewlett-Packard and BP provide useful counterexamples, although the deterioration in their businesses reflected problems that extended beyond the scandals themselves.
Intel dismissed Krzanich in June 2018 after discovering a past relationship with an employee that breached company policy. The shares lost 2.4% on the day, despite the company simultaneously raising its quarterly guidance. The immediate operating outlook remained strong, but Intel was already experiencing problems with its manufacturing roadmap and increasing competitive pressure. CFO Bob Swan initially took over on an interim basis before becoming permanent CEO seven months later. The shares were 12.2% below their pre-news close after three months and 9.0% below it after twelve months. Subsequent delays to Intel's 7nm manufacturing process contributed to its loss of technological leadership, including to Nvidia.
At HP, Hurd's departure was followed by a turbulent succession. Leo Apotheker arrived three months later but lasted just eleven months as the company repeatedly reduced guidance, abandoned its webOS devices and agreed to acquire Autonomy. The shares initially stabilised but were 4.7% below their pre-news close after three months and 31.9% below it after twelve months, falling much further as the strategic difficulties mounted. By October 2012, they had lost roughly 70% of their value from the level immediately before Hurd's resignation.
BP's experience is different again. Bernard Looney resigned in September 2023 after admitting he had not been fully transparent with the board about past relationships with colleagues. The shares fell 2.8% on the first trading day and were 22.7% below their pre-news close after twelve months. Murray Auchincloss, the finance chief who had helped develop BP's energy transition strategy, initially maintained that direction before the group announced a more substantial reset in February 2025.
Best Buy provides an example where the departure eventually helped create the conditions for a turnaround. Brian Dunn resigned in April 2012 amid an investigation into his relationship with an employee. The shares fell 5.9% on the day and were 6.7% below their pre-news close after three months as the retailer struggled against Amazon and falling profitability. Yet the appointment of Hubert Joly later that year eventually transformed the business through improved execution, price matching and a stronger online offer. The shares were 9.6% above their pre-news close after twelve months, and the subsequent recovery was substantial.
There is also evidence that investors can welcome the removal of an unsuccessful executive. Kohl's shares rose 7.6% on the day in May 2025 when Ashley Buchanan was dismissed over undisclosed conflicts involving a personal relationship and vendor transactions. The shares had already fallen sharply during his brief tenure. They subsequently enjoyed an extraordinary speculative rally, up 60.1% on the pre-news close after three months and 118.8% after twelve months. The contrast illustrates why the direction of the shares should ultimately be assessed alongside the company's operating performance.
The academic evidence suggests a broader cost
There is a more substantial body of evidence beyond these individual examples. In a 2018 study published in the Journal of Financial Economics, an examination of 219 incidents found the immediate loss of shareholder value averaged 1.6%, rising to 4.1% when the CEO was involved. A subsequent summary of the research found that the companies continued to underperform over the following year, with cumulative losses of 12–14%.
The consequences also extended beyond the share price. The researchers identified weaker operating margins, lower returns on assets and a decline in the acquisition of major customers and joint venture partners. The evidence suggests that personal misconduct can undermine trust in management and damage commercial relationships, even where the behaviour has no direct connection with the company's operations.
This is particularly relevant to Nvidia. The allegations surrounding Huang raise questions about judgement, transparency and potentially national security, areas where the reputational consequences could be more significant than those arising from an otherwise private relationship.
Huang's departure presents a different challenge
The historical cases point towards the importance of continuity in management and strategy. McDonald's and Nestlé promoted experienced internal executives immediately. Boeing maintained operational momentum under an interim CEO before appointing James McNerney four months later. Booking.com also operated successfully with an interim chief executive partly because it benefits from strong tailwinds.
HP and Intel suffered more difficult transitions, with management instability adding to existing competitive and strategic challenges. Nevertheless, the experience of Booking.com demonstrates that the appointment of an interim CEO does not automatically signal a poor outcome. What matters is whether the organisation can continue executing its strategy while the board decides who should lead it.
Nvidia is unusually exposed to this question. Huang co-founded the company in 1993 and was its only chief executive until his resignation. His decision to invest in CUDA, opening Nvidia's graphics processors to general-purpose computing long before AI became commercially significant, was instrumental in establishing the company's competitive advantage. The platform subsequently became central to the development of modern AI, creating an ecosystem of software, developers and hardware that competitors have struggled to replicate.
The scale of the transformation has been extraordinary. Data centre revenue reached $193.7 billion in fiscal 2026, compared with approximately $15 billion three years earlier, and now accounts for almost 90% of group sales. Nvidia has become central to the AI investment programmes of the world's largest technology companies, with Huang playing a prominent role in product development, relationships with hyperscalers, sovereign AI agreements and discussions with Washington over export controls.
The organisation also reflects his leadership. Nvidia has an unusually flat management structure, with numerous executives who reported directly to Huang and no designated permanent successor, with CFO Colette Kress now interim CEO.
The underlying investment case will ultimately determine the outcome
Nvidia enters this crisis in good health. Unlike Intel in 2018 or BP in 2023, there is no obvious deterioration in operating performance accompanying the scandal. Demand remains strong, and its technological leadership and software ecosystem remain in place after Huang's departure. The challenge is whether his successor can preserve the pace of innovation and the confidence of Nvidia's largest customers. The national security allegations introduce a separate risk, particularly if they lead to regulatory restrictions or commercial consequences.
History suggests that strong businesses can recover from an unexpected change of leadership, particularly where operational continuity is maintained. Nvidia's shares have already fallen about a quarter since the allegations emerged, suggesting that considerable uncertainty is now reflected in the valuation. Provided the board secures a credible permanent successor and the investigation reveals no wider commercial or security implications, the recent sell-off could prove excessive. The immediate uncertainty is considerable, but history suggests that the quality of the underlying business should ultimately prevail.
All companies mentioned in this article are not recommendations. If you need further indepth analytics please contact your Mirabaud Equity Desk.
Related Insights
Stay Informed
Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest insights and market perspectives from our experts.